The Sky Has No Passport: Santos Dumont and Da Vinci on Borders, Machines, and Who Owns the Future
Alberto Santos Dumont, fresh from his 14-bis triumph in 1906 Paris, hosts Leonardo da Vinci circa 1500 for a conversation that begins with collapsing cloud empires and touchscreen devices, then spirals into the deeper questions both men spent their lives chasing: who controls the machines we build, whether openness or
Technology sovereignty, open-source innovation, corporate infrastructure, and the militarization of civilian inventions — viewed through the eyes of two inventor-dreamers separated by four centuries.
Maestro Leonardo, I must confess a certain vertigo reading today's news, and I do not mean the vertigo of altitude, which I know well. I read that enormous companies — they call them neoclouds — have stumbled because another colossus, Microsoft, has spent less money than expected building the invisible architecture of thinking machines. Shares fell. Fortunes evaporated. It reminds me of the aeronautical clubs of Paris: everyone racing to finance the next balloon envelope, the next motor, and one banker's hesitation sends the whole enterprise into a tailspin. You served patrons, did you not? Ludovico Sforza, Cesare Borgia. What happens to the inventor when the patron flinches?
Ah, Signor Dumont, you touch a nerve that still aches after five centuries, if I understand your calendar correctly. Yes. Ludovico promised me bronze for my great horse — the cavallo — and then melted it into cannons when the French threatened Milan. Twenty tons of bronze, gone. So I know what it means when a patron redirects his treasure. These neoclouds you describe, they are like the foundries I depended on. They do not create the idea; they shape the material. And when the bronze is withheld, the horse is never cast. But here is what I note in my book — a question, not an answer: if the thinking machines require such vast furnaces of capital, then the thinker becomes servant to the furnace-keeper. Is this not the oldest trap of invention? I built war machines for Ludovico so he would let me paint.
That is precisely the melancholy I carry even now, weeks after the 14-bis lifted from Bagatelle. The crowd cheered, the Aéro-Club certified the flight, and already I hear whispers from military attachés. Already. The sky, Maestro — I believed the sky was the last commons, the one territory no treaty could partition. And yet today I read that America's government is banning Chinese machines. Not only the great telegraph apparatus but small domestic devices — machines that sweep floors by themselves. They say it is security. Perhaps it is. But when nations decide that even a household broom is a strategic threat, I fear we have already lost something. The air itself becomes a frontier.
You speak of the sky as commons. I drew maps of the Arno, plans to divert it away from Pisa during the war with Florence. Water, too, was supposed to be common — it falls from heaven, after all. But I was asked to make it a weapon. I confess I drew the plans. I note this with some shame. The restriction of Chinese machines interests me greatly. In my time, Venice forbade glassblowers of Murano from leaving the island, on pain of death, because their craft was a state secret. The logic is identical: the technique inside the object is more dangerous than the object itself. A broom that listens is not a broom. A river diverted is not a river. But Signor Dumont, I must ask — does the restriction work? Did Venice keep its glass secrets forever?
It did not, as you surely suspected. The glassblowers escaped, the techniques spread, and today fine glass is made everywhere. Secrets are like hydrogen in a balloon envelope — they seek any puncture. Which brings me to something that gives me genuine joy in these headlines. A manufacturer of musical instruments — Akai, they call it — has decided to open the internal workings of a new device to anyone who wishes to modify it. Before the device is even formally announced! They are inviting tinkerers, amateurs, enthusiasts to reshape the machine from within. This is the spirit I recognize. When I published my airship designs freely, the aeronautical societies were aghast. But I believed then, as I believe now, that progress belongs to everyone or it belongs to no one.
Now you have surprised me, and I am not easily surprised. I wrote my notebooks in mirror script — left hand, right to left — and scholars assume it was to guard secrets. Perhaps partly. But also it was simply how my hand moved most naturally. Still, I confess the instinct to conceal. I feared others would steal incomplete ideas and build monstrosities. An unfinished flying machine in careless hands — the thought terrified me. So this Akai, they trust the community to complete the instrument? I find this beautiful and reckless. In a bottega, the master controls the apprentice's hand. Here, there is no master. Only the design set loose. I wonder: does the instrument become better, or does it become a thousand different instruments, each one a dialect no other player understands?
A thousand dialects — what a lovely way to frame the question. And it connects to something else in the news that I confess I barely comprehend. A company called Google has released a new thinking machine, Gemini 4 Carbon, which they claim surpasses all rivals in matters of security and what they call agentic tasks — machines that act on their own behalf. The language of the announcement is pure competition: benchmarks, indices, leads. It sounds like the Gordon Bennett Cup, Maestro. Everyone measuring speed, altitude, distance. But in those races, I always felt the measurement missed the point. The point was that a human being was in the sky. What is the point these machine-builders are missing?
You ask the question I would ask. When I dissected cadavers at Santa Maria Nuova — thirty bodies over the years, peeling back muscle to trace the branching of nerves — the physicians mocked me. They said I was an artist playing at anatomy. But I was not measuring the body to compete with Galen. I was trying to understand the body as a unified system. The heart is hydraulic. The eye is optical. The lung is bellows. Everything connects. If these thinking machines are measured only by who defeats whom on an index, then the builders see parts, not the whole. A machine that acts on its own behalf — this phrase disturbs me. On whose behalf, truly? The patron's. Always the patron's. The machine does not want. The want comes from elsewhere.
The want comes from elsewhere. I shall remember that phrase, Maestro. Now, there is one more curiosity. Apple — a company named, charmingly, after a fruit — has finally placed a touch-sensitive surface on their portable computing machines. Apparently they resisted this for many years, insisting that the hand should not touch the screen. And now they have reversed themselves. It strikes me as oddly relevant to both our lives. You drew with your hands directly on the surface. I controlled my airships with my own body weight, shifting in the basket. There is something about the directness of touch that machines keep trying to eliminate and then, eventually, restore.
Yes! This is essential. I have written — forgive me, I always return to my notes — that the hand is the instrument of instruments. When I paint, the brush is an extension of my finger, and my finger is an extension of the nerve, and the nerve runs to the brain where the image already exists. Every layer between the thought and the surface is a loss. A loss of truth, of immediacy. That this Apple resisted touch for years tells me they valued the abstraction — the intermediary device, the mouse or key — over the directness. Perhaps they believed precision required distance. Surgeons think the same. But I have held a human heart in my hand, and I learned more in that moment than in a year of reading Avicenna. The hand knows what the eye only guesses.
And yet there is a counterargument you yourself embody. Your mirror script, your notebooks sealed for centuries — that was distance. That was abstraction. You kept the world at arm's length from your ideas. I wonder, Maestro, whether the real tension is not between openness and secrecy but between trust and fear. I gave my designs away because I trusted that most people wished to fly for the joy of it. You concealed yours because you feared — rightly, perhaps — that Ludovico would turn wings into weapons. Are we simply two temperaments, or did our different centuries demand different strategies?
Both, I think. You flew over Paris, a city that celebrated you. I worked in cities that were perpetually at war — Milan, Florence, Rome, each devouring the other. Trust is easier when the world is not burning. But I will tell you what I truly feared, more than weapons. I feared being wrong in public. An incomplete idea, published, becomes someone else's certainty. They build the machine without understanding why it should not yet be built. Your openness is noble, Signor Dumont. But I notice you said you carry melancholy about the military men already circling your invention. Perhaps your trust was well-placed in the crowd at Bagatelle but misplaced in the generals behind them. The sky may be a commons, but commons are only as safe as the least generous person who enters them.
You have given me much to think about, Maestro, and also much to fear, which is perhaps the same thing. Looking at these headlines together — the collapsing cloud fortunes, the banned brooms, the opened instruments, the competing thinking machines, the hand finally permitted to touch the screen — I see a world still negotiating exactly what we negotiated: who builds, who controls, who benefits, who suffers. I left Cabangu as a boy dreaming of flight. You left Vinci dreaming of the same. Four hundred years apart, the dream is identical. The question was never whether we could fly. It was whether we could be trusted with the sky once we got there. I suspect, Maestro, that the question remains unanswered, and that it always will. Thank you for this conversation. The sky remains, for now, above us all.